Tuesday, October 09, 2018

The Irish Border. The Remainers last stand.

Can someone please tell me why Mrs May and others keep perpetuating the myth that we can't have a free trade Brexit because of the Irish border?  

Oh, it’s easy to understand why Remainers like Mrs May wish us to think that.  But the reality is really rather different.  

Firstly, you have to understand that not everyone on the EU set up is a raving, swivel eyed and only out to destroy the UK.  Oh yes, there are many of them that’s true.  But let’s give credit to one man, Donald Tusk.  He is perhaps the only one in the negotiations who actually realise that the EU and the UK are best served by a good deal.  He realises, as he said to Mrs May, there are no cherries on the cake.  This was interpreted by some as a sleight at Mrs May.  The reality was, he was just telling the truth.  And nor would we want cherries as an adornment.  What we want is the substance of the cake.

So in his pragmatic way, last week Mr Tusk confirmed that Canada +++ is still on the table.  It is an option.  So why Mrs May keeps saying there is no other option other than Chequers is beginning to sound rather silly.  Yes, there are strings attached. They could be negotiated.   But substantially, it’s a deal I think most would find acceptable.  Except the SNP who threaten to vote down any deal that comes though the UK parliament.    

Back to the border.  You can get Canada +++ and retain the border as barrier-free as it is today.  The only thing stopping it happening is the Remainer politicians like Mrs May who see it as a way to scupper any agreement and keep us under ECJ rule.   

And what does today’s border look like?  Yes, the tarmac changes colour.  But look closely around it.  Search it on GoogleMaps.  There is a complete infrastructure already in place in the form of ANPR cameras.  Does it cause disruption?  Does anyone complain that both sides are recording details of every vehicle that crosses the line on the tarmac?   And what of the other stuff, VAT, tax, excise and currency?  A border already exists for all these things.  So no new border.  The only thing needed to be added is Customs.  And to help Mrs May, there is a business in London that has just done such a project, in six months, for Singapore. 

So leaving the single market and the customs union, a promise, or should I say a threat, made by David Cameron, Vince Cable, Nick Clegg, George Osborne, Gordon Brown, Nicola Sturgeon and others for a Canada-style FTA adds one more item:  customs.     

But, let’s take an independent view from Lars Karlsson, a former director of the World Customs Organisation.  He has concluded that existing computerised customs clearing methods used across much of the world mean physical border infrastructure is unnecessary.  And from the UK?  Well, the chief executive of HMRC notes that companies currently traversing the border complete VAT returns electronically in a way that could be applied to future customs declarations.  Additional physical inspections by officials already happen away from the border.  So the Irish Border? The only people who think it’s a problem are those that want to stop us leaving the EU.

Monday, October 08, 2018

What did we vote for?

Once upon a time, as all good stories begin, there was a referendum.  It had been called to see if people wanted to stay in or leave the European Union.  Lots of people said, it will be good to get out of what had become in effect a parliament and legal system that was above our own UK parliament and those of the devolved nations.  Others took a different view.  They thought staying in this new super state was actually a good idea.   

Which was fine.  It gave a very clear line of what this was all about.  Sovereignty.   But the remain people decided that this wasn’t enough. They wanted to make a second case.  They wanted people to think that leaving was economically bad too.    

Indeed, using taxpayer’s money, the then government lead by David Cameron, aided by the Liberal Democrats and the Labour Party, spent £9m of our money to lay out reasons other than sovereignty as to why we should stay.   So what did they say?  Well, one thing they said was voting Leave meant leaving the Single Market, including  introducing potential trade barriers, paying tariffs and even reverting to WTO rules.  There are countless examples of Messrs Clegg, Cameron, Brown, Osborne and Ms Sturgeon saying just that.   

Look at the words they used about the so called Single Market.  Voting Leave meant “less access”, “losing full access” and “uncertainty and risk”.  Or as Will Straw put it such easy to understand language, “we must be absolutely clear about what this means: Britain would not be part of the Single Market”.    This was echoed by former chancellor Alistair Darling:  “those wanting to leave the EU want to pull Britain out of the Single Market, which would mean introducing tariffs and barriers to our trade”.   
And even the then prime minister had his words of doom that “What the British public will be voting for is to leave the EU and leave the Single Market”.     

To be honest, I am not really how much clearer those in power could have been.   Leave meant Leave.     

So those who now say we didn’t know what we were voting for, really?  We knew exactly what we were voting for.

Wednesday, October 03, 2018

Let’s do some arithmetic, Mrs May.

Over 80% of our economy is Business to Business within the UK.  So that makes our overseas trade worth a max of 20% of our total trade.    

Now, not all of that 20% overseas is with the EU.  Indeed only 35% of that 20% of trade is with the EU.  So, do the arithmetic,  65% of our overseas trade is actually out with the EU.

That means that out of all the trade we do in the UK and beyond these shores, only 7% of our total trade is actually with the EU.      

I know this a simplistic way of looking at it.  And I know there are different ways of measuring what exactly is trade.  Any yes, you may come up with a few percentage point s of a difference.  

You could, for example, argue that some of our components come from the EU.  That’s true.   But the inescapable truth is we actually don’t need the EU as much as Remainers keep telling us we do.     

Quite why Mrs May then says today in her speech that it is up to the EU to come up with a counter offer to Chequers, I have no idea.  

All it can mean is she is still looking to negotiate even more away even though, as your simple arithmetic will have demonstrated in these last few seconds, we don’t need to negotiate.  We don’t need to give anything away.

Saturday, September 29, 2018

Stop flogging a dead horse, Mrs May.

What do all of the 200 people listed at the bottom of this post have in common?  They run their own successful businesses. Many of them trade globally.  They are the kind of entrepreneurs that keep this country on the move.  They are real people who risk their own money to run real businesses that provides 60% of employment in the private sector.    

One thing they all believe in common?  They believe Britain deserves better than Chequers.

In a letter to the Telegraph today they outline their belief that the Chequers deal “is a muddled compromise that suits no one on either side of the referendum divide.   The “common rulebook” that Chequers accepts offers the EU carte blanche to dictate policy, stifling innovation and leaving us a passive rule-taker”.

In other words, even though we leave the EU, the EU still can veto what the UK wants to do.  How any democrat could come up with such a deal beggars belief.  Add to that, “Chequers also hobbles the greatest economic opportunity of Brexit: that of free trade agreements with old allies and new friends round the world”.

The reaction at Salzburg showed Chequers is doomed.  When you are flogging a dead horse, change horses.  There is no shame in that.   Indeed, it shows courage.    If Mrs May doesn’t show that courage now the result will be more uncertainty and continuing Government paralysis. 

Just remember, Donald Tusk in March 2018 offered an almost identical agreement to the one reached between Canada and the EU.  That deal does not tie Canada into accepting rulings from the ECJ.  

Why is Mrs May so incapable of swallowing her pride and actually doing something that will benefit not just the UK but the EU too?  Why can’t she go back and say ok Donald, bit late, but let’s work on that offer? 

The problem is becoming clearer.  And the problem is Mrs May and her clear desire to continue to be locked into judgements of the European Court of Justice.  I can’t think of any other reason for her behaviour, because it’s certainly not in the national interest.   

Indeed, I believe the 200 below understand more what is in the national interest than people like Mrs May or Mr Oliver Robbins who have never worked in what economists call the productive sector.  The people who make money so that governments, through taxation, can spend their money.

So, next time someone tells you that businesses don't want to leave the EU, don't let them get away with their contribution to Project Fear.  Just remind them of all these successful business leaders that employ so much of the UK workforce want to do just that.  Get out.

Tom Bohills   Co-founder, Alliance of British Entrepreneurs and Head of Legal, Red Deer Edward Harden   Co-founder, Alliance of British Entrepreneurs and Co-founder, JustSeats.org  
Tim Martin   Chairman, JD Wetherspoon
Lord Flight   Former shadow Conservative chief secretary to the Treasury
Chris Kelly   Chairman, Keltruck Limited, West Midlands
William Hynett   Chief Executive, Britten-Norman, London
Anthony Gibbon   Dairy Farmer, Garreg Farm, Carmarthenshire
Geoff Oborne   Owner, Geoff Oborne Gardening Ltd, West Sussex
Nick Cresswell   Managing Director, Glebe Engineering Ltd, Staffordshire
Tim Trotter   Chairman, Glenfern, London
Simon Beart   Director, Guardian, Kent
Lance Forman   Owner, H. Forman & Sons, London
Arabella Arkwright   Partner, Hatton Country World, Warwickshire
Johnnie Arkwright   Director, Hatton Ltd, Warwickshire
Martyn O'Connor   Managing Director, Heatshine, Ceredigion
Alex Bourne   Founder and Director, Hinpack Limited, Suffolk
Rachael Furness   Director, Hitvo Ltd, Cheshire
Trevor Honeyman   Chairman, Honeyman Group Limited, County Durham
William Bavin   Managing director, House of Marbles & Teign Valley Glass, Devon
Darren White   Managing Director, Ibex Risk Management, North Yorkshire
David W Ford   Founder and Director, Ingenica Solutions Ltd & Lightpoint Medical, Hampshire
Jason Mark Rutter   Managing Director, Jason Mark Rutter Ltd, Worcestershire
Miles Brough   CEO, JBM International Ltd, Staffordshire
John Crampton   Owner, JC Fabrications, Surrey
Max Johnson   Director, Johnson Insurance Services, North Yorkshire
Phil Valori   Co-Founder, JustSeats, London
Kevin Davies   Director, KDM Events, UK wide
Colin Low   Founder, Kingsfleet Wealth, Suffolk
Ajay Jagota   CEO, KIS Group & Dlighted, Tyne & Wear
Charles Breese   Director, Personal Capacity, London
John Turnbull    Owner/CEO, M8 Software, Merseyside
John Davies   Owner, Manufexl, West Glamorgan
Roger Hall   Owner, Marlowe James, Derbyshire
Richard Ayres   Director, Maroon Analytics Ltd, London
Nigel Roberts   Managing Director, Megasteel Limited, Wiltshire
Colin Pettit   Proprietor, Miko Coffee, Cambridgeshire
Peter Roberts   Director, Mill-Tek Limited, Devon
Christopher Evans   Director, Ministry Developments Ltd, Wiltshire
Keith Wannell   Director, MM Enviro Ltd, West Sussex
Dr Alan Watt   Owner, Monkey Tower Ltd, Essex
Ben Walker   Owner, MonkeyFist Construction and Precision Planning, South Gloucestershire
Mark Gilbert   Director, MuscleDiet, Staffordshire
Dr Tom Walker   Founder, MyLash, Edinburgh
Ian Harris   Proprietor, N Bloom & Son, London
David Pilsworth   Author, New Novelist
Nigel Green   Managing Director, NLG Associates, London
Alan Graves   Director, Norcon Computers Ltd, Derbyshire
Paul Jenkins   Director, North IT, County Durham
Ross Bland   Director, Oakleys Fuel Oils, West Midlands
Henry O'Lone   Managing Director, Oare Limited, East Sussex
James Bromley   Director, One Ten OneHundred Ltd, Aberdeenshire
Karl Pearsall   Director, Original Thing Ltd, Middlesex
Alistair Bruce   Partner, Original Design Company, Derbyshire
Allison Wild   Managing Director, Oxford Biosciences Limited, Oxfordshire
James Dean   Chairman, Patrick Dean Limited, Lincolnshire
Tim Stephenson   Executive, Personal Capacity - 'Financial Services Recruitment Consultant', UK Wide
Peter Harris   Managing Director, Peter James Group, Dagenham
Tim Price   Managing Director, Price Value Partners, North Yorkshire
Mark Norton   Managing Director, Prima Bakeries Ltd, Cornwall
Gareth Bott   Founder, R.E.P Air Services, Loughborough
David Furness   Director, Rapierstar Ltd, Cheshire
Simon Boyd   Managing Director, ReidSteel, Dorset
Colin Rennie   Principal, Rennie Park Associates, London
Debbie Flint   Founder, Retreats For You, Devon
Ian Goodyer   Director, Reydoog Ltd, East Sussex
Dr Tom Brook   Managing Director, Santel Ltd, London
Neil Sawyer   Director, Sawyers Consulting Limited, Bristol
Manuel Alsoni   Signing in a personal capacity
Justine Thomas   Director, Simrush Ltd, Norwich
Christopher Neal   Non Executive, Director, Sirius Petroleum Plc, London
Mark Rushe   Director, Stonehouse Homes, Lancashire
Barbara Stratton   Director, Stratasys Ltd, Somerset
Oliver Tickner   Founder/Director, Streetwire, London
Bruno Prior   Director, Summerleaze Ltd, Berkshire
Angus Macdonald   Chairman, SWRNewstar, Hampshire
Andrew Hamilton   CEO, Syn2gen Ltd, Essex
Tom Scollen   Managing Director, T&G Training, County Durham
Graham Mitchell   Owner/CTO, T2 Technologies Ltd, Dorset
Mark Foster   Director, Taxhelp Accountants Ltd, East Sussex
Michael Webster   Director, Telum Media, London
Patrick Wallace   Owner and Chairman, The Arkle Group, London
Sir David Ord   Director, The Bristol Port Company, Bristol
Terence Mordant   Chairman, The Bristol Port Company, Bristol
Ken Thomson   Managing Partner, Thomson Harrower Fencing, Dunfermline
John Biggin   Managing Director, TruckEast Ltd, Northamptonshire 
Tony Young   Creative Director, Urban Fires Limited, London
Dr Michael McGetrick   Managing Director, UtterSense Ltd, Hertfordshire
Andy Ockleton   Director, Uttoxeter Brewing Company, Staffordshire
Simon Rowland   CEO, Veritas International, London and Dorset
Nicholas Timms   Managing Director, War on Waste Ltd, Dorset
Bruce Smith   Senior Partner, Westminster Consultants, London
Alistair Macmillan   Founder and Managing Director, White House Products Ltd, Renfrewshire
Steven Farrall   Senior Partner, Williams Farrall Woodward, Ipswich
Peter Thompson   Director, Woodpecker Inn (Estates) Ltd, Cheshire
Stuart Leasor   Managing Director, Woodstock Leasor Limited, London
Daniel Hodson   Signing in a personal capacity
Danny Corrigan   Signing in a personal capacity
Sandra Dangoor   Signing in a personal capacity
Richard Royden   Managing Director, Royden & Co, London
Hunter DuBose   Managing Partner, Spitfire Capital Advisors, London
Matthew Byrne   Director, Greengage Lighting Limited, Greater Manchester
Lord Vinson
Lord Daresbury   Director, Daresbury Estates Ltd, Cheshire
Robert Law   Managing Director, AGD Equipment, Warwickshire
Arthur Jones   Founder, ANJ Executive, London
Jon Moulton   Chairman, Better Capital LLP, Guernsey
Brian Yeardley   Founder, Brian Yeardley Continental, West Yorkshire
Mark Wheatley   Common Councilman, City of London, London
Elaine Harries   Managing Director, County Couriers Ltd t/a Action Express, Northamptonshire
Richard Stoughton   Chairman, Crossflight Limited, Berkshire
Dave Bentley   Owner, Dave Bentley Ecology Services, Greater Manchester
David Kirk   Director, David Kirk & Co, Cheshire
Christopher Nieper   Managing Director, David Nieper Ltd, Derbyshire
Bill Good   CEO, Diverco, Worcestershire
William Jones   Chairman, Global Village, Buckinghamshire
John May   Founder, Hillhouse Nexus, Essex
Graham Hutton   Founder, Hutton Collins Partners LLP, London
Rupert Gather   Chairman, Invest UK, London
Julian Morgan   Joint Managing Director and Owner, KPM-Marine, Birmingham
Tim Parker   Chief Executive, Messels, Surrey
Oliver Hemsley   Founder, Numis Securities, London
Edgar Miller   Managing Director, Palladian  Limited, London
Emma Pullen   Managing Director, The British Hovercraft Company, Kent
Richard Patient   Managing Director, Thorncliffe, London
Ian Herbert   Chief Executive Officer, Vistair Ltd, Bristol
Andrew Kitchen   Director, LK2 Architects Ltd, Lincolnshire
Alastair James Robb   Director, Marlborough Tiles, Wiltshire
Lesley Hollingshead   Director, MPS Financials & Accountancy Ltd, Berkshire
Adrian Hawkins   Chairman, Weldability-Sif, UK Wide
Spencer Clarke   Director, 121prodata Ltd, Gloucestershire
Anthony Smethurst   Owner, A S P Stampwise Rubber Stamp Ltd, Greater Manchester
George Bowen   CEO, Able Lyons Consulting, UK and Australia
Clive Underdown   Chairman, Advantage Group, Suffolk
Stephen Britt   Managing Director, Anchor Storage Solutions, Suffolk
Andrew Dixon   Owner, Andrew Dixon Photography, West Midlands
Angela Cook   Managing Director, Angies Transport Services Ltd, Lincolnshire
Scott Fletcher   Founder, ANS Group, Manchester and London
Colin Penny   Director, APG Equine Limited, Devon
Annette Penny   Director, APG Equine Limited, Devon
Tristan Lee   Director, Archerfield Homes, Surrey
Matthew Snowden   Independent Artist, Matthew Snowden Art, Wales
Philip Brooker   Managing Director, Arun Microelectronics Ltd, West Sussex
Geoff Greenall   Owner, Ascot Shoes, West Midlands
Andy Richards   Director, ASL Catering Agency Ltd, Cheshire
Paul Dorey   Director, Aspidistra Software, Devon
Iain Baillie   Founder & Executive Director, Asset Match, London
Robert Neal   Director, B&N Hydraulics, West Midlands
Neil Ballantyne   Managing Director, Ballantynes of Walkerburn, Scottish Borders
Danny Cox   Owner, Barcs Woodworks, Essex
Mark Fox   Director, BDSX, South Yorkshire
Neville Wright   Director, Beeson Wright Ltd, Cambridgeshire
Charles Buckley   Director, Belport Capital, Oxfordshire
Alistair Emery   Director, Belport Capital, Oxfordshire
Clive Blackman   Director, BHCG Ltd, Hertfordshire
Peter Bishop   Managing Director & Founder, Bishop GmbH, Hamburg
Steve Barson   CEO, Burley Appliances, Rutland
Didier Delmer   Owner, Business Booster 247
Steve Smith   CEO, Buzz Networks Ltd, Dorset
Stephen Wilkinson   Managing Director, CAS Recruitment, South Tyneside
Adam Cleary   Director and Chief Executive, Cavenham Capital, London
Kevin Bell   Director, CDM 2014, Essex
Steven Wake   Managing Director, Chapters Property Development And Investment Limited, Wiltshire
Said Amir Faqirzada   Owner, Chelsea Tailors, London
Chris Hills   Managing Director, Chris Hills Financial Consultancy Ltd, Hampshire
Patrick Hurd   Managing Director, Cintis International Ltd, Farnborough
Steve Ody   Owner, Citrus Travel, Sussex
Steve Hardeman   Managing Director and Co-Owner, Clevedon Fasteners Ltd, West Midlands
Geoff Townley   Owner, Commercial Gas Consultants, Hampshire
Chris Chatfield   Managing Director, Compass Travel, West Sussex
Chris Kirk-Blythe   Director, Complex Legal Limited, Manchester
David Buik   Market Commentator, Core Spreads, London
Guy Cowling   Director, Cowling & Wilcox, London
Gwyndaf Jones   Managing Director, Cwrw Da Cyf, Wales
Gregg Reed   Owner, Damson Square Properties Ltd, West Midlands
Patrick Eatherden   Owner, Dapapod, London
David Campbell   Professor of Law, Lancaster University
David Watson   Owner, David Watson Transport, Norfolk
Michael Bilewycz   Managing Director, Decisis Limited, London
Christopher Gower   Executive Deputy Chairman, Direct Nickel Projects Limited, London
Judith Donovan   Chairman, DIY Direct Marketing, North Yorkshire
FCA Hamilton   Director, Dscribe Ltd, London
Kevin Dowd   Professor of Finance and Economics, Durham University/Economists for Free Trade
Nick Berry   Managing Director, Early Oak Reproductions Ltd., East Sussex
Ivor Chivers   Managing Director, Eco Solutions Limited, North Somerset
Julie Williams   Owner, EdgeC, London and Essex
Richard Debenham   Senior MD, Elevation Lift Services Ltd., Essex
Mick Kelly   Managing Director, Elmesthorpe Projects Ltd, Leicestershire
Dr John Hart   CEO, Endocrine Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Hampshire
James Blott   Former CEO and Entrepreneur, Engineering and Defence Sectors
Eddie Pilsworth  Managing Director, EP Industries, Derbyshire
John Theobald  Managing Director, Erimus Management Ltd, London
Flavius Fernandes   Director, ERPSirius Ltd, Essex
Nick Sellick   CEO, Estate Insurance Group, London
Dermot Glynn   Founder and Senior Advisor, Europe Economics, London
Richard Foleher   Technical Director, Everything Voice Ltd, West Yorkshire
John Fifield   Chairman, Fifield Glyn Ltd, London
Stu Taylor   Managing Director, Firenze Partners, London
Bill Blair   Founder, Fluxible, Lancashire
Amy Folkes   Director, Folkes Holdings Ltd, West Midlands
Constantine Folkes   Chairman and CEO, Folkes Holdings Ltd., West Midlands
Glyn Johnson   Owner and Director, G.H Johnson Plant & Machinery Sales, Derbyshire

Tuesday, September 11, 2018

The utter incompetence of the CAA

I was at a meeting a few months ago at the Scottish Parliament.  We were talking about leaving the European Union.  Almost everyone around the room was moaning about how they may have to be forced at the last minute to make preparations.   

This was in sharp contrast to the businessman who lives in the productive sector of the economy who told the room, “the moment the vote happened we started preparing, as any prudent business would, for the worst of options.  And we did.  Within six months we were ready for no deal.” 

Now, leaked notes from the Civil Aviation Authority reveal that they are nowhere near ready.  Instead of spending the last two years preparing it appears they have done precisely nothing.   

The documents paint a picture of the CAA being an organisation scrambling to make the necessary preparations for a no-deal Brexit and the UK dropping out of the aviation single market altogether.   

The advice to stakeholders issued by the CAA's head of flight operations, Captain Rob Bishton, says: "If the UK no longer continues as an EASA member, UK issued licences, ratings and certificates may continue to display EASA references beyond 29 March.   In this instance, licences, ratings and certificates will be reissued by the UK CAA."   

This is not news.  This was known two years ago.  So can someone at the CAA explain what they have actually been doing for the past two years.  This should all have been in place a year ago.

All this news item shows is the utter incompetence of the leaders at the CAA and other such bodies.

Sunday, September 09, 2018

Just two words.

What two words link Donald Trump, Serna Williams and Remainers?   

“Petulance”.  And “Me, me, me”.  Ok, that’s four words.  But the link is really pretty simple and straightforward.   

They all think only they are right.  And they all want to challenge authority.  And they show a remarkable disregard for the rule of law.  And they all set a terrible example of how to live.    

Trump.  How often has he tried to exceed the powers that the American people allow their president to have.  If he is ever convicted of a criminal offence will he seriously be of the mind that he should pardon himself?  Basically, don't like what people say?  Abuse them. 

Ms Williams.  A liar and a thief she called one of the best umpires on the planet.  So next time a child rocks up to an umpire on a junior tennis tournament and abuses them, you know where their role model comes from.    But I suppose she is just behaving like Trump.  Don't like what people say?  Abuse them.  Welcome to the new America.  A nation of intolerant people.

Remainers.  How many of them want to stage a coup and overturn the democratic wishes of the electorate in the biggest plebiscite the nation has ever seen.   Of course in this case, it is the Remainers who are seeking to be the thief, stealing a democratic vote.  Don't like how voters voted?  Abuse them.

Tuesday, September 04, 2018

The tide is not for turning.

In today’s Telegraph Justine Greening writes an excellent piece trying to make sense of where Mrs May has got us.  She alludes to the story of the "graceful and magnificent" King Canute, who died on 12th November 1035.  

In the story, Canute was like Mrs May   He had flattering courtiers around him. Call them the Ollys for the sake of a name. The Ollys tried to persuade their master that he had super natural powers, to create amazing deals with the tide no one else could make.  Or in the EU negotiations they could confound economic and legal logic.   

But Canute was wise.  He knew this was rubbish.  And to prove it he plonked a chair in the path of an incoming tide to prove he didn’t have the power to turn it. Point graphically made.   

Mrs Mays problem is she doesn’t realise she is not in control.  And the tide is still coming in.   

Here endeth the lesson for today.

Monday, September 03, 2018

As all good stories begin....

Once upon a time Mr Barnier offered a Canada +++ .  And, surprise surprise, that deal was also wanted by many of those in favour of leaving the EU.  But, even bigger surprise, it was also wanted by many of those who didn’t want to leave the EU, that is, the ones that had accepted the democratic wish of the people.   They realised that Canada +++ is actually a pretty good deal for the EU and the UK.    

And all was fine till Mrs May thought her Chequers proposal would be better.  And so we are in the mess we are in.   

Given no one seems to like Chequers, let’s just do the deal that seems to unite everyone.  Canada +++!

With good will (and yes I think Mr Barnier is a person of goodwill, though a hard negotiator) this can be done and dusted easily by 29th March 2019.  End of story.   

What’s so difficult Mrs May?  

What is so strange in this story is it is Mr Barnier that is leading the charge to a credible Brexit and thus spearheading the democratic mandate given to Mrs May there by creating clean break.  But he is a Gaullist after all, so it makes sense.